The Supreme Court has stressed that a code of investigation for police is required to be devised so that the guilty do not walk free on technicalities "as they do in most cases in our country".
In its judgment, a bench of Justices B.R. Gavai, J.B. Pardiwala, and P.V. Sanjay Kumar said that it is deeply concerned with the "disappointing standards of police investigation" which seem to be the invariable norm.
The bench referred to the 2003 Report of Dr. Justice V.S.Malimath’s 'Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System' and 239th Report of Law Commission of India where it was observed that the principal causes of low rate of conviction in our country included inept and unscientific investigation by the police and lack of proper coordination between police and prosecution machinery.
"Despite passage of considerable time since these gloomy insights, we are dismayed to say that they remain sadly true even to this day," it said.
The apex court said that it is high time that a consistent and dependable code of investigation is devised with a mandatory and detailed procedure for the police to implement and abide by during the course of their investigation so that the guilty do not walk free on technicalities, as they do in most cases in our country.
"The manner in which the police tailored their investigation, with complete indifference to the essential norms in proceedings against the accused and in gathering evidence; leaving important leads unchecked and glossing over other leads that did not suit the story that they had conceived; and, ultimately, in failing to present a cogent, conceivable and fool-proof chain of events pointing to the guilt of the appellants, with no possibility of any other hypothesis, leaves us with no option but to extend the benefit of doubt," said the Supreme Court while setting aside the conviction and sentences of all the three accused on all counts.
The top court was considering a criminal appeal against an order of the Madhya Pradesh High Court confirming the death penalty for two of the accused in a 2013 murder case of a 15-year old boy.
In early September, the Supreme Court had said that India does not have a sentencing policy till date and in the absence of such guidelines in India, the courts go by their own perception about the philosophy behind the prescription of specified penal consequences for a particular crime taking aggravating and mitigating circumstances of a case into consideration.
SC stays Calcutta HC’s order cancelling school jobs; rebukes Bengal govt for alleged recruitment scam
The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed a Calcutta High Court order, which cancelled 25,753 appointments in teaching and non-teaching posts in the state-run schools made by the West Bengal School Service Commission (WBSSC) in 2016.
Landslides hit train services in few NE states, affects supply of essentials, fuels
Movement of passengers and transport of goods, including essentials, has been affected in southern Assam, Tripura, Mizoram and Manipur for the past two weeks, due to the restricted movement of trains in the region, officials said on Tuesday.
With voting in four seats in Assam, polling complete in all 25 LS seats in NE
With the completion of polling in four Lok Sabha seats in Assam on Tuesday, elections in all the 25 parliamentary constituencies in the eight northeastern have been completed now.
Have 'irrefutable evidence' of India's involvement in recent targeted killings, claims Pakistan
Director General (DG) of Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), Major General Ahmed Sharif Chaudhary, said on Tuesday that Pakistan has "irrefutable evidence" of India's involvement in the recent targeted killings of various individuals in the country.
Work to form multi-polar world order will continue, says Putin after beginning fifth presidential term
The 71-year-old leader was quick to add that the conversation - including on issues of security and strategic stability - is possible "only on equal terms, respecting each other's interests" and "not from a position of strength".
J&K: Top terrorist commander among 2 killed in Kulgam encounter
A top commander of the banned militant outfit Lashkar-e-Toiba’s frontal organisation The Resistance Front (TRF) was killed along with another terrorist in an encounter with the security forces in J&K’s Kulgam district.
No relief for CM Kejriwal, SC likely to hear case on May 9
The Supreme Court bench, which initially decided to pronounce its judgement on Tuesday on the interim bail plea of incarcerated Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal in the excise policy case, will most likely take up the matter again on May 9 or the next week.
'Those on bail are batting for Muslim reservation', PM Modi’s fierce counter to Lalu’s quota pitch
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday tore into Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) chief Lalu Prasad Yadav for making a fresh quota pitch for Muslims, saying the INDI Alliance cannot see beyond ‘appeasement’.